From Distance: NFL vs NBA (Uncomfortable Issues)
2019-11-27four point play….
1. The NFL is certainly not the most “forward thinking” league we have. At its best, the NFL provides a venue for us to see humans of drastically different sizes and shapes combine power and speed like nothing else in the world of sports.
It is a beautifully intricate game, easily the most complex because of its individual play structure. Eleven guys each have specifically coordinated actions that another group of eleven must stop.
For as much as I love basketball, its Xs and Os pale in comparison to America’s favorite game. A free-flowing game like basketball and soccer simply doesn’t have the same opportunity for complicated play-calling as a game that features stoppage between four specific downs.
Football is a glorious sport at its essence, but it is now impossible to enjoy the NFL without thinking and feeling about two very pronounced issues.
The first, and likely less controversial, is the concussion issue. I’ll try not to delve too deeply into this one. We all know the research at this point and it is abjectly terrifiying.
Venice’s famed art Biennale featured a looping video of football players stumbling around after taking huge hits. I couldn’t watch it without feeling ill. I won’t subject you to it now.
Seriously though, if a famed art festival is using your sport’s biggest issue to highlight a negative aspect of the human condition, you might be in trouble.
My solution? Take off the helmets (not like our man, Garrett. We shall get to him in a second).
I mean ditch helmet wearing all together. A guy might die every now and then by accident, but one wouldn’t have repeated head trama like we currently have.
No one is using their head like a weapon if they aren’t equipped with armour. Yes, rugby also has its problems even without helmets, but it seems that most damage occurs near the line of scrimmage for football players when they slam their heads into other heads on literally every down.
Without a helmet, people learn to tackle again, the spearing disappears, and a person’s normal sense of caution returns.
Acute injuries would probably go up. That is why we are in this predicament to begin with. Our idiotic society simply cannot deal with long-term consequences.
2. Whether it football, the economy, or climate disaster, we always look the other way until what was once a manageable impending doom becomes inescapable catastrophe.
Humanity can be pretty smart when our back is up against the wall. We are just terrible at recognizing exactly when that wall slams against us. Heaven forbid we listen to an expert or a million.
So yeah, the second some guy is dead on contact because football no longer features on-field weaponry, folks will scream about how unsafe it is.
Typical Americans. It is fine if people die. It is their choice to be modern day gladiators and they are handsomely paid for it. Just make sure you die later out of sight so we can enjoy our Sunday afternoon without having to be truly confronted by the reality of the sport we love.
3. While we have some consensus building regarding the concussion issue, we seem to remain hopelessly divided on inherent racism in the sport.
The lack of black coaches has been discussed and addressed by the Rooney Rule without it really affecting much change.
More damning is this: There has never been a black team president in the history of the league.
Never. That is beyond ridiculous.
It should then come as no surprise that the NFL tried its best to pull one over on Colin Kaepernick and the American public at large.
The moment the NFL decided to hold this random workout, skeptical fans were right to wonder whether it was a legit shot, or simply a way for the NFL to “prove” that Kap actually isn’t a viable player.
When the NFL put language in the waiver forbidding Kapernick to have his own recording of the workout while also closing it to the media, it was clear as day that the NFL planned on going full collusion.
“Well, we really wanted to give him a chance, but his skills just aren’t there anymore. A real shame.”
That is what they wanted out of this farce of a tryout. Kap could have had the best workout ever and it wouldn’t have mattered. They were setting him up.
Fortunately for us, Kap is no fool, and he was not about to be played. He isn’t hiding his skills. He isn’t just a cause. That dude wants to be one of the gladiators subjecting himself to possible death because of his love of the game.
And yet, because the NFL is tied to incredibly conservative sponsors and owners, Kap is on the outs. ESPN talking heads like Stephen A. Smith make sure to keep their paychecks by not going against the NFL.
The Myles Garrett situation further illustrated the insanity that are NFL race relations. There is simply NO way that a black QB doesn’t get suspended for doing what Mason Rudolph did.
Zero.
I won’t say whether Rudolph used racial slurs or not. We can’t know, though considering how much Rudolph played the victim in the post-game, I don’t have a lot of faith in his integrity.
Regardless of that potentially consequential slur, his physical actions against Garrett to instigate the whole thing would have absolutely been suspension worthy if he were a black player.
Feel free to say, “that is just speculation” and I will be free to say you are an idiot. Make all parties black linemen or defensive backs and every one of them is suspended at least a game. You know it is true.
I am in no way absolving Garrett’s actions. I am simply pointing out the double standard in the NFL’s justice system. The NFL has not earned the benefit of the doubt.
4. In the NBA, Luka Doncic shows that racism can be a part of player evaluation in our favorite league as well.
While it is true a primary reason NBA folks didn’t take Luka seriously enough had as much to do with their ignorance to the quality of Euro League play as it did the color of his skin, I have a hard time believing that Luka would have been described as unathletic as frequently as he was, and still is, had he not been white.
Luka is a Paul Pierce level athlete only with elite lateral and start and stop quickness. Pierce was rarely described as unathletic, simply as “not a freak athlete”.
That is usually how an elite player with only adequate leaping ability is described. With Luka, he only gets bemused smirks.
I am obviously far more ok with this racism than I am with the NFL version. Why?
Because white skeptics are actively rooting for Luka to succeed while the same is not true for most black QBs. Many white GMs and reporters were as skeptical of Luka’s potential as any black GM, but the underlying sentiment remains “it would be awesome to have another Larry Bird.”
One is an almost cheerful trope that movies are made around, ie “White Men Can’t Jump”, while the other one mirrors our failures in race relations in the society at large.
The justice system has different rules for different communities. They make movies about that too, but they are the kind that make you want to march against injustice.
Well, unless you are the type of person who fails to see the difference between these two examples of racism. If you are having trouble, I ask you this. Do you identify with one guy more than the other?
Just a question as I would imagine most of you have far more in common with American Colin Kaepernick than Slovenian Luka Doncic.
Oh, you mean it might be that other thing? Yeah? Then you are part of the problem.
Bonus: Stop complaining about load management. Either we want to see these guys play for as long as possibe, providing a decade of playoff joy, or we are more concerned about a random regular season game in November.
Hockey players play a much more intense game than basketball and I don’t hear about this load management crap with them. These players are a bunch of babies and they should be held accountable.
Also it’s hard to read these articles without drowning in Ben’s arrogance.
Except he’s right about it all.
Don’t read them if you feel that way. Simple solution.
This generation of NBA players are soft. Period.
Maybe you should pony up and write something for the blog yourself?
What is that picture of, Ben? Venice?
Yep, taken by my GF.
I don’t understand why there isn’t a giant foam cushion on the outside of helmets.
It wouldn’t do much. Concussions are from your brain hitting the inside of your skull. Its the speed and sudden stopping of the collision.
I worked with the guy, Vijay, who is selling the fan insurance for tickets when players sit out. Now that load management is a hot topic thing he’s getting some free advertising on ESPN and more business opportunities. To the article, a large difference between the NFL and NBA is the owners. The owners in the NFL have so much power. Look at the Donald Sterling saga. Imagine it was Jerry Jones saying those things. Do you think anything like that plays out in the NFL? Jones probably gets a large fine and we move on. I also see a… Read more »
The issue for me is the entirely different rule set. How do you have a line of scrimmage with guys rushing each other to block/get to the qb without helmets? Seems way too dangerous. I feel like football and rugby are way too different to say not having helmets would work the same as rugby. You can’t even block in rugby. Massive difference right there. I don’t think you could have a line of scrimmage and o and d lines. People were dying in the era before helmets and they were still primarily leg tackling back then. Agree on the… Read more »
Was totally serious about the helmet removal. Exactly my thinking on the backyard ball.
The best sarcasm is the hardest to detect. I can’t tell if the no helmets thing is sarcasm or not, and that’s why I enjoy it so much. As for load management, the NBA needs to just end back to backs and shrink the schedule. I complain about load management because the NBA is airing crappy games and people are paying to see stars not play.
I thought it might be, but it seemed too reasoned and thought out. I mean rugby players don’t wear helmets, but I am fairly certain they have a lot different rules regarding the scrum versus football’s line of scrimmage. Scrum starts together. In football, lines rush towards each other. There aren’t really stoppages in rugby for tackling save for fouls. I also don’t believe blocking is allowed. Don’t think it is transferable, save for leg tackling.
He’s not the first to point out that pads and helmets lead to more concussions. There would be more skull injuries but fewer brain injuries.
Someone with a medical background explain that to me. That seems like an oxymoronic scenario.
Not sure if Ben was completely serious or not, but the usual argument is not no helmets, but go back to leather helmets…
That just seems more dangerous to me, but I have zero medical background. I think just enforcing tackling rules much more strictly, teaching proper technique, and requiring much stricter concussion protocols (limiting the number a player can be diagnosed with before being unable to play anymore) along with better injury compensation is more realistic. Of course then you might get pushback from the player’s union about limiting guy’s careers and subsequently their earning potential. Regardless, in my opinion, the NFL is really the one league that needs guaranteed contracts considering the risks the players are taking. I get the difficulty… Read more »
DITTO WHAT MIKEO SAYS !!!!
Bump the number of games to 100 and encourage load management. That would be a fun experiment.
I’ve been a proponent of a much shorter season for many years, especially since the number of playoff series/ games skyrocketed (sometime in the ’90s, was it?). A regular season of 65 (or even fewer) games is plennnn-ty. We’d just be missing a bunch of non-games in February and March, where guys either don’t give a crap, or sit. Of course, it would mean less revenue, so it’ll never happen. 75 games might be possible, but even that is a long shot. Players and owners love them their money. Good piece as always, Ben. I haven’t paid attention to the… Read more »
Giannis and Kawhi are about the only ones for me. When locked in, both can still be so dominant defensively I couldn’t pass them up.
Also you make a great point about the increased number of playoff games. Believe first round went from 5 to 7 in the early 2000s. 1984 was when it went to four rounds.
Yeah, Giannis, especially. It’d be a tough call for me since Doncic is freaking 20 years old. Love Kawhi, but I’d be scared of his long term health. But Giannis and Luka, boy, that’d be a great and terrible decision to make.
I don’t think taking off helmets is a solution. You don’t have to spear people to get a concussion. Accidentally knocking heads in a non-tackle situation could do it just as easily. The pile would be a huge issue. They simply need to enforce head first tackles more, or better yet prevent players from playing again if they get more than one or two concussions in a career. And pay out a certain fair percentage of the rest of their contract. That would have the same effect as taking off the helmets. It would definitely make guys more careful. As… Read more »
Except for Giannis, the Joker, Gobert… Our reigning MVP and DPOY both came from Europe. Seems like these superstar guys coming from Euroleague are happening more frequently, not less.
True. But those guys weren’t high picks. Hence my point about the scouting not being there. Even now, I don’t think teams have the scouting structure in Europe and hence will still be more comfortable with NCAA prospects. I suspect the lack of scouting is the real reason why euro prospects fall, not latent racism.